Once-a-week Hebrew School lowers Jewish identity: The minimal education paradox

A 1995 study by Hebrew University sociologist Steven Cohen found that all forms of Jewish education improve adult Jewish identity – except for once-a-week Hebrew or Sunday school. The study found that those who attend Sunday school score lower on standard measures of Jewish identity than people who had no Jewish education at all. (But, of course, those who go to Hebrew School more often than do have more ties to their Jewish identity.)

first-grade classroom in the Vitkin School in Tel Aviv 1973
first-grade room at the Vitkin School in Tel Aviv, 1973, The Archives of Education, Tel Aviv University, from the Pikuiki site

Hebrew school: How much is enough?

The Impact of Varieties of Jewish Education upon Jewish Identity: an Inter-Generational Perspective
By Steven M. Cohen, Jewish Agency for Israel (JAFI), 1995

This study assesses the impact of several forms of Jewish education upon composite measures of Jewish identity for teenagers and for their parents. The analysis controls for each generation’s parents’ Jewishness as well as for other factors. All forms of Jewish education, except Sunday school, are associated with higher levels of Jewish identity in both generations. The putative effects of day school, including non-Orthodox day schools, are especially pronounced. Among adults, all forms of Jewish education, EXCEPT Sunday school, are associated with lower rates of intermarriage. The likely impact of youth groups, Israel travel on intermarriage rates are rather small.

The impact of varieties of jewish education upon jewish identity: An inter-generational perspective

Link 2Link 3link 4

 

Related articles

Linking the silos. How to accelerate the momentum in Jewish learning today. Jack Wertheimer

Learning Jewishness, Jewish Education and Jewish Identity

Research Studies on the Impact of Day School Education

The Impact of New Models of Congregational Jewish Education

What is to be Done? Policy Responses to the Shrinking Jewish Middle. Steven M. Cohen

Will Your Grandchildren be Jews: Updated (Aish.com)

_______________________________

Merrimack Valley Havurah Coffeehouse Logo

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s